Menu

Quantic Nightmare: Why We Shouldn’t Tolerate Unhealthy Studio Culture

It’s 2018! This behaviour has long been unacceptable!

Quantic Dream

Whether you believe the accusations or not, Quantic Dream is in hot water.

Unless you’ve been living under a rock, you’ve probably heard about Quantic Dream’s video game designer, David Cage, and video game producer, Guillaume de Fondaumière being accused of some very shocking things. One of them being sexual assault, as well as predatory behaviour in the workplace.

Now I’m already aware what some will and do think about this whole situation: innocent before being proven guilty. I get that, wanting both sides of the story is human nature. But I also think you’re missing the point of these accusations in the first place, which is this: racism, sexism and abuse in the workplace is a very real, damaging thing and each accusation should be taken seriously.

Eurogamer’s article describes the controversy surrounding Quantic Dream perfectly. They state: “Quantic Dream leaders David Cage and Guillaume de Fondaumière are accused of inappropriate behaviour, overworking staff and colluding in – or at least turning a blind eye to – a schoolboy culture involving sexist and racist jokes.”

Colluding in or turning a blind eye to, it doesn’t matter at all. Engaging or allowing sexism/racism to not only happen but cultivate in the workplace is unacceptable, and dare I say, poor management in general? Both Cage and Fondaumière have a responsibility to the people who work under them, to make sure they feel safe and respected in their place of work, but it seems they’ve utterly failed to do that.

“Nazism is bad.”

Nazism has no place in society. That isn’t an opinion: it’s a FACT.

Actually calling it bad, even in a way that is very, very sarcastic, doesn’t do it justice. Nazism is bloody disgusting and intolerable and under no circumstances should we, as a society, try and justify the authoritarian and fascist behaviour involved in it.

However, this doesn’t seem to be true for Quantic Dream. One of the most shocking things that Le Monde’s report included, as translated by Eurogamer, was “Quantic Dream’s collaborators in sexual positions, adorned with homophobic or sexist slurs, or even made up to look like Nazis.” Now before I get comments saying “this is accepted in Europe because it’s considered a costume, almost like fancy dress,” let me just stop you right there: no it bloody isn’t. Nazism is not a joke, it isn’t a costume and the fact Cage and Fondaumière have allowed this behaviour to happen under their noses is infuriating and wrong.

While many will chalk this behaviour up to ‘schoolboy culture’, it disregards how a video game studio should act and treat each other in the first place: professionally and with the utmost care and respect. There is no reason at all to subjugate your fellow colleagues with pornographic images as well as fascist material.

For a studio that’s next game is about intelligent Androids potentially overthrowing their human masters, it seems ironic that former employees are turning against Quantic Dream’s top dogs and the behaviour they have allowed to grow right under their very noses.

Hiding won’t help 

Quantic Dream

Cage has tried to hide against these allegations by using Jesse Williams and Ellen Page as props.

With all these accusations thrown at him, Cage has labelled said accusations as “ridiculous, absurd and grotesque.” Which is fitting, because that’s how I feel about Cage’s use of Jesse Williams and Ellen Page as a shield in the first place.

There’s nothing more eye-roll worthy than the classic “I can’t be homophobic/racist, I know a gay/black person!” Which, you know, is what Cage did.

The full quote, from Cage, says: “You want to talk about homophobia? I work with Ellen Page, who fights for LGBT rights. You want to talk about racism? I work with Jesse Williams, who fights for civil rights in the USA… Judge me by my work.”

But just because you aren’t shouting you support Trump or setting gay people on fire doesn’t actually excuse or invalidate these accusations against you. I just want everyone to know that.

Yet what’s really interesting about this is if we really are to judge Cage by his work, then it would only be fair to consider that Ellen Page, who came out after Beyond Two Souls by the way, once explored legal action against Sony over nude scenes that were involved in the game. Without her consent.

Let me just be very clear: it doesn’t matter who you work with when it comes to discrimination and the fact that Cage has attempted to hide behind Williams and Page against these accusations doesn’t look good for him at all.

Quantic Dream’s nightmare isn’t ending anytime soon

True or not, these accusations will linger.

While Cage is the main focus of most of these accusations, Fondaumière doesn’t get off the hook quite so easy either. He too is accused of making inappropriate remarks towards other staff, as well as pushing himself onto them at evening parties.

Of course, both Cage and Fondaumière have denied these allegations against them, with Quantic Dream’s twitter offering a statement that you can see below.

Regardless of Quantic Dream’s statement, it does seem that despite Sony blacklisting the journalist who broke the story in the first place, Quantic Dream will be left to face the upcoming weeks of questions on their own. Which they seem to be up for, considering two employees from Quantic Dream have spoken out against these allegations already.

What we do (or at least should) know, is that regardless of whether the pictures involved were from 2013 or 2017, behaviour that promotes Nazism, racism and homophobia is disgraceful and should not be in society, never mind the workplace. If you disagree with that then I can’t help you, and frankly, don’t want to.

However, what happens next for Quantic Dream remains to be seen, though I doubt this will be the last we hear from David Cage or Guillaume de Fondaumière.

 

Aimee Hart
When not sleeping (which is...a lot of the time), Aimee is writing up a storm for her latest ideas. Hailing from the city Birmingham, she's had a love for video games since playing Star Wars Episode 1: Racer on the PC with her trusty joystick! Since then she's developed a firm love for RPGs and JRPGs and considers them her second love, straight after dogs. Her favourite games are: Tales of Berseria, Dragon Age II (don't judge!), Final Fantasy X and Pyre. You can hear her ramble about them @honhonitsaimee on Twitter.
  • ObsessedGeorge

    How is everyone sure that this journallist is legitimately telling the truth?

    • Beth Meadows

      He’s not the only one to report on it, just the only one to see major backlash right now.

      • J.j. Barrington

        You mean like the two current employee denying the claims?

    • Aimee

      Hi George!

      First off, I’d like to say thank you for being polite. I truly appreciate it.

      Secondly, you’re right. We do have no way in knowing that the journalist is 100% telling the truth. So, why am I writing an article about it and putting myself behind this group of ex-Quantic Dream employees?

      Mostly because I think each accusation, whether proven false or not, should be taken seriously. Therefore I’ve taken it seriously and decided to simply write about it. David Cage has a bit of a history, so it doesn’t surprise me that this sort of thing has occurred. I felt that it was my duty, as a human being, to talk about why racist/sexist/homophobic behavior shouldn’t be accepted in the workplace. And that goes without even touching the news of alleged sexual assault.

      I know that may not satisfy you. But that’s my answer. Thank you again, George.

      • ObsessedGeorge

        No problem, I just don’t want to believe that this is true because I love David Cage’s and Quantic Dream’s work so much. The guy always got a lot of heat for his “games” by people who say he makes movies instead of games. Like the child/domestic abuse scene we saw on Detroit: Become Human, everyone jumped the hate/complaint bandwagon. I don’t know why everyone is so sensitive about stuff like this nowadays as it has always been part of the entire film industry’s life. What difference does it make if it is in a game? The way I see it, in the game it’s better because you have the power to do something about it while in films, you just watch it happen.

        Now if these accusations are true then why doesn’t the rest of the team come out and say it if they know? Why protect their bosses? I don’t know.

Join Our Discord!

Join Our Discord!

Click the icon above to join our Discord! Ask a Mod or staff member to make you a member to see all the channels.

Review Archives

  • 2018 (37)
  • 2017 (434)
  • 2016 (427)
  • 2015 (172)
  • 2014 (91)
  • 2013 (28)
  • 2012 (11)
  • 2011 (9)
  • 2010 (12)